How To Build a List of Likely Sellers in 2025

By Terry Trexler

Hi I’m Terry Trexler and I’ve built a top-selling real estate team that covers 12 states and growing. I just moved to LPT Realty after being with another brokerage for years. The splits are better, the revenue share is better, and it’s honestly the perfect business model now that we can build on the existing success of proven cloud brokerage models. I invite you to check out LPT Realty. Move your license over to us. We’re a brokerage focused on listings and profitability.

The real estate landscape is always evolving, and finding motivated seller leads in 2025 is more competitive than ever. With an increase in homes on the market and buyers becoming more selective, sellers now have more options, and as a result, real estate agents must be strategic and focused in how they generate leads.

So, where can you find the best seller leads in today’s market? Here are three proven strategies to help you connect with motivated sellers and grow your business:

1. Reconnect with old buyer leads. Do you have old buyer leads tucked away in your CRM that you haven’t followed up with in a while? These contacts can be a goldmine. Many of these buyers have become homeowners over the past two to five years and may now be considering selling because they’ve outgrown their homes or want to reassess their living situation.

Reach out with a personalized message offering a free home valuation or a cash offer. You’ll be surprised how many respond with interest in knowing the current value of their property. These leads already know you, so a thoughtful call or email could be the spark that gets them to sell.

2. Dive deeper into your own database. Many agents overlook the true potential of their own database. Instead of chasing expired listings or unqualified leads, focus on the past clients you’ve worked with. These relationships are your best opportunity for repeat and referral business.

Implement a consistent communication plan, such as the 36-touch strategy, which involves sending two educational videos and one lead-generating email each month. Share market trends, home value updates, and useful tips to stay top of mind. When your past clients decide to sell, you want to be the first person they think of.

3. Use lead generation services. If you’re looking for targeted, motivated seller leads, lead generation services can be very effective—if you choose the right ones. Services that promote quick cash offers tend to attract sellers who are serious and motivated to sell fast.

While these leads may not convert immediately and often receive multiple calls from other agents, persistence pays off. With smart follow-ups and clear communication of your value, you can convert these leads into successful listings. Focus on engaging quickly and demonstrating how you can solve their problems better than the competition.

Finding motivated seller leads in 2025 is absolutely possible with the right approach. Whether you reconnect with old buyer leads, tap deeper into your database, or utilize targeted lead generation services, the key to success is consistency, relationship-building, and providing real value.

If you’re ready to take your business to the next level with a proven system for building a strong pipeline of seller leads, I’m here to help. Reach out by call or email today, and let’s work together to grow your real estate business!